Solving cash flow problems
AQA also says:
Spec content: Evaluating solutions to cash flow problems.
Students should be able to: evaluate possible solutions to cash flow problems, including re-scheduling payments, overdrafts, reducing cash outflow, increasing cash inflow and finding new sources of finance.
Identifying and Solving Cash Flow Problems
When a cash flow forecast reveals a projected negative closing balance, the business must act before the shortfall arrives. AQA identifies five categories of solution, each with different costs, speeds, and suitability depending on the cause of the problem.
Solutions to Cash Flow Problems
-
Re-scheduling payments — negotiating with suppliers and creditors to delay or spread out outgoing payments, or negotiating with customers to bring forward incoming payments. For example, asking a supplier for extended credit terms (60 days instead of 30) reduces the immediate outflow; offering customers a small discount for early payment accelerates the inflow.
Advantage: Costs nothing if negotiations succeed; addresses the timing mismatch directly.
Disadvantage: Suppliers may refuse; repeated requests can damage supplier relationships; discounts for early payment reduce revenue. -
Overdraft — arranging or increasing a bank overdraft facility to cover short-term cash shortfalls. The bank allows the account to go into a negative balance up to an agreed limit.
Advantage: Flexible and immediately available; interest paid only on the amount drawn.
Disadvantage: High interest rate; bank can withdraw the facility; not suitable for long-term or structural cash flow problems. -
Reducing cash outflow — cutting costs to reduce the amount of money leaving the business. Options include: reducing stock orders; delaying non-essential capital expenditure; cutting discretionary spending (marketing, training, travel); renegotiating supplier prices.
Advantage: Directly reduces outflow without creating new obligations.
Disadvantage: Cutting costs can damage quality, operations, or long-term competitive position if taken too far; some costs (rent, loan repayments, wages) cannot easily be reduced at short notice. -
Increasing cash inflow — generating more cash coming into the business. Options include: increasing prices (if the market will bear it); running promotions to stimulate sales; chasing outstanding invoices more aggressively; selling surplus assets.
Advantage: Addresses the root cause if the problem is insufficient revenue.
Disadvantage: Takes time to generate results; price increases may reduce volume; asset sales are one-off. -
Finding new sources of finance — arranging additional external finance: a bank loan, a new investor, a government grant, or a sale-and-leaseback of assets.
Advantage: Can provide significant cash quickly; a loan provides a structured repayment plan.
Disadvantage: Loans carry interest costs; new investors may demand equity; finance applications take time and are not guaranteed; increases the business's financial obligations.
Key Takeaways
- Five solution categories: re-scheduling payments, overdraft, reducing outflow, increasing inflow, new finance.
- The best solution depends on the cause and severity of the problem — a temporary timing mismatch suits an overdraft; a structural revenue shortfall requires increasing inflow or finding new finance.
- Act early — a cash flow forecast gives advance warning that enables proactive solutions rather than emergency ones.
- Some solutions (cost-cutting, discounts for early payment) have hidden costs — the right solution minimises total commercial damage, not just the immediate cash shortfall.